Curated Resource ( ? )

Deliberation

Deliberation

my notes ( ? )

Met Marc-Antoine parent via FotL, who's focused on "design of new tools and approaches to aid collective decision making", particularly under the following conditions:

  • deadline: a course of action must be developed and implemented in a certain amount of time
  • complexity: issues are too complex to be well understood by a small group of people;
  • diversity: "opinions are so diverse that the set of options, or even the very definition of the problems are not agreed on, at least initially"
  • size: those involved are too numerous to simply meet as a group.

Many issues have these characteristics: decisions on "national policy ... have unforeseen indirect impacts in the social fabric and the natural environment. However, decision processes ... including representative democracy do not ensure... [those] most directly affected by a decision will be able to provide input".

Those processes must be able to allow "input from as many stakeholders as possible, ensure all are heard... [and] arguments will not be ignored just because they are complex or require specialized knowledge. This, I propose, can be achieved through collective authoring of collective projects".

We don't have the tools. The closest tool is probably wikis, but they're not designed to "achieve a binding decision for its users... [Wikipedia] allows to register dissent on issues that may remain unresolved indefinitely".

In any case, no tool can solve all the issues - the best I guess one can hope for is a tool that helps a group at least find an agreed majority view, and/or perhaps several minority views.

So what would such a tool - and the associated processes - look like?

Read the Full Post

The above notes were curated from the full post maparent.ca/Deliberation/index?utm_source=pocket_mylist.

Related reading

More Stuff I Like

More Stuff tagged collective intelligence , fotl , ma parent

Cookies disclaimer

MyHub.ai saves very few cookies onto your device: we need some to monitor site traffic using Google Analytics, while another protects you from a cross-site request forgeries. Nevertheless, you can disable the usage of cookies by changing the settings of your browser. By browsing our website without changing the browser settings, you grant us permission to store that information on your device. More details in our Privacy Policy.

I agree